Saturday, November 27, 2010

Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens debate religion

Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens debate religion

Click to play

Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens debated the idea 'Religion is a force for good in the world'

Former UK PM Tony Blair has defended the role of religion in global affairs, in a televised debate in Canada with atheist columnist Christopher Hitchens

Mr Blair, a Catholic convert, said faith was a force for good and it was "futile" to attempt to drive it out.

But Mr Hitchens, who is terminally ill with cancer, argued religion forced people into doing terrible things.

In a vote after the debate, the audience voted two-to-one in Mr Hitchens' favour.

A 23-country poll paid for by the debate's Canadian organisers suggests the world is evenly split on the issue.

The confrontation took place in front of a sell-out audience of 2,700 people in Toronto's Roy Thomson Hall.

The two men were asked to debate the motion: "That religion is a force for good in the world".

'Cruel experiment'

The BBC's Paul Adams, who was in the hall, said it was a carefully moderated and largely polite debate, without the rumbles of thunder many had been hoping for.

Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens in Toronto, Canada (26 Nov 2010)

Tony Blair

  • Former Labour PM, aged 57
  • Brought up in a Christian family, he says he became a practising Christian while studying at Oxford University
  • Converted to Catholicism in 2007
  • Launched Tony Blair Faith Foundation in 2008

Christopher Hitchens

  • Sixty-one-year-old journalist, author and critic
  • Refused to take part in prayers at his Christian boarding school
  • Says his "bohemian and rackety" lifestyle may have caused his cancer of the oesophagus
  • Regarded as a leader of the "New Atheism"

Mr Blair, a lifelong Christian who converted to Catholicism after leaving office in 2007, acknowledged that "horrific acts" had been committed in the name of religion.

But he said that a "world without faith would be morally diminished".

He said the most challenging issue for people of faith was how to explain the relevance of ancient scripture in the modern world.

Mr Blair also insisted that his decision to support the US invasion of Iraq was based on policy and not on his faith.

Mr Hitchens, who has previously described Christianity, Judaism and Islam as the "real axis of evil", said religion was "a cruel experiment whereby we are created sick and ordered to be well".

Humans gained little, and compromised their freedom, by acting like sheep, said Mr Hitchens.

He said religions created a "celestial dictatorship" which was "greedy for praise from dawn to dusk". He won a laugh from the audience and Mr Blair when he compared such an authority to the North Korean leadership.

In the end, the audience seemed more impressed, and perhaps more entertained, by Mr Hitchens, says our correspondent, and he won the debate by a margin of two to one.

Global poll

Prior to the debate, the organisers had commisioned a 23-country poll on religion by Ipsos.

Analysis

Anyone expecting verbal pugilism, or a blood-soaked gladitorial contest, with Tony Blair as the Christian thrown to the hungry atheist lion, might have walked out into Toronto's chilly night a little disappointed.

It's not that the two men didn't debate with conviction, but the format engendered politeness - this is Canada, after all- and somewhat stifled argument.

And perhaps the lion is wounded. Mr Hitchens is starting to look frail, in the throes of a cancer that he acknowledges will probably kill him. Tony Blair, by contrast, looks a picture of well-dressed health.

When asked which of each other's arguments they found convincing, both men were polite, respectful.

Tony Blair admitted that it wasn't always easy for people of faith to explain the importance of scripture in the modern world.

Mr Hitchens admitted no such intellectual difficulties, saying he preferred the awe-inspiring wonders of the cosmos to what he sees as the destructive teachings of organised religion.

An audience of 2,700 sat in rapt attention, frequently applauding both men. But a random sample afterwards tended to tell a consistent story. People weren't necessarily opposed to Mr Blair's argument, but they found Mr Hitchens the more persuasive speaker.

Some 48% of the 18,192 people questioned by Ipsos took the view that "religion provides the common values and ethical foundations that diverse societies need to the thrive in the 21st Century".

Fractionally more - 52% - supported the view that "religious beliefs promote intolerance, exacerbate ethnic divisions, and impede social progress in developing and developed nations alike".

Rich countries were less likely to see religion as a force for good than poor countries - the main exception being the United States, where 65% said it had a positive impact.

The Ipsos poll, conducted in September, found that Europe was the region most doubtful about the benefits of religion, with just 19% in Sweden agreeing that it was a force for good.

At the other end of the scale, in Saudi Arabia and Indonesia, it was seen as a positive force by more than 90% of those questioned.

Within North America, there was a pronounced divide. In Canada, only 36% agreed with the positive view of religion whereas 64% saw it as a negative force - figures almost exactly the reverse of those in the US.

Christopher Hitchens has continued his outspoken attacks on religion in interviews as he is treated for cancer of the oesophagus.

He is scathing about those who suggest his illness might lead him to retract his atheism.

In a BBC Newsnight interview to be broadcast on 29 November, he says he is not afraid of death, but regrets the fact that it will cause distress to friends and family.

Blair v Hitchens on the BBC

  • BBC World Service radio will air the Blair-Hitchens debate on 4 December, followed by Radio 4 on 11 December
  • It can be viewed on BBC World News and the News Channel on 1 January 2011

In comments released by the debate's organisers he said it was "bizarre" that Mr Blair, a Catholic since 2007, had converted "at one of the most conservative times for the Catholic Church, under one of the most conservative popes".

Speaking before the debate, Tony Blair said: "The good that people of faith all over the world do every day, motivated by their religion, cannot be underestimated and should never be ignored."

It could, and should, be a force for progress, he said.

Graphic showing religion poll results

Click to play

Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens debated the idea 'Religion is a force for good in the world'

23 comments:

  1. This is what I am talking about - it is not a question of religion, it is a question of faith. We all have faith in something and there is no need to build churches and clans in the name of it.

    ReplyDelete


  2. I browse I imagine your web site is obviously fascinating and weblog articles
    with this distinctive unique web site and h -AS acquired collections of tips which were amazing


    my website - 풀싸롱
    (jk)

    ReplyDelete
  3. . It is encouraging you that there are nations whose public pay is less $800 and ethical quality of under five years age youngsters is about 26%.Islamic quotes about life

    ReplyDelete
  4. A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.
    Shohar Se Talaq Ya Divorce Lene Ka Wazifa
    Shohar Ki Narazgi Khatam Karne Ka Wazifa

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for your nice sharing article for us. I’m a blogger and i have a news related with more website running on wordpress. I used CMS for my different site and you share here details about CMS for any wordpress site. That’s really helpful to us.
    How To Get Your Ex Boyfriend Back
    Vashikaran To Get My Ex Love Back

    ReplyDelete
  6. 토토사이트
    배트맨토토
    토토



    Your blog is great. I read a lot of interesting things from it. Thank you very much for sharing. Hope you will update more news in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 스포츠중계
    해외스포츠중계
    스포츠토토

    Thanks for sharing.I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.

    ReplyDelete
  8. 스포츠토토
    먹튀검증
    토토

    Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tony Blair is a Prick

    ReplyDelete
  10. Students can use a service to get their assignments done. In some cases, they even pay the writers to complete their assignments. However, it is important to make sure that the assignment is completed with quality content. This is why you need to choose the right assignment writing service.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Im extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout in your blog

    ReplyDelete
  12. The site style is perfect, the articles is actually nice :D Good job, cheers

    ReplyDelete
  13. Fabulous entire performance on the subject of doing this business site

    ReplyDelete
  14. Amazing performance located on doing this website online. Keep doing it

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very good effectiveness via this valuable blog. I just loved browsing this

    ReplyDelete
  16. شرط بندی بازی انفجار با بونوس برای تجربه شرط بندی رایگان

    حالا که آموزش بازی انفجار را فرا گرفته اید لازم است یک نکته که ما برای شما یادآور شویم که آن هم مربوط به بونوس بازی انفجار می باشد. در واقع شما می توانید تجربه بازی انفجار بدون پول را با بونوس برای خود رقم بزنید. این گونه که ابتدا به سایت های ارائه دهنده بونوس مراجعه می کنید و بعد از شارژ حساب کاربری به پشتیبانی آن سایت در خواست تایید بونوس می دهید. در کمتر از چند دقیقه در خواست شما تایید می شود و می توانید با توجه به درصد بونوس فعال روی سایت بونوس دریافت کنید. بگذارید توضیحات بالا را در قالب یک مثال برای شما توضیح دهیم تا به برتری بی چون و چرای این روش شرط بندی بیشتر پی ببرید.

    ReplyDelete
  17. "Blair's defense of religion as a force for good falls short against Hitchens' compelling argument highlighting the dark side of faith. The audience's overwhelming support for Hitchens underscores the growing skepticism towards the positive impact of religion in our complex world."
    New York Divorce Laws Adultery
    New York Divorce Law Alimony

    ReplyDelete
  18. When discussing Tony Blair and Christopher, one may not immediately think of a dissertation writing service. However, their leadership styles and political decisions could be fascinating topics for a dissertation. A reputable dissertation writing service could help craft a well-researched and insightful analysis of their roles in modern politics.





    ReplyDelete
  19. The debate between Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens on religion sparked intellectual fireworks, showcasing contrasting perspectives on faith, reason, and society. As Blair championed the role of religion in shaping moral frameworks and fostering community cohesion, Hitchens fiercely advocated for secularism and rational inquiry.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.

    Also feel free to visit may web page check this link Ship Search.

    ReplyDelete
  21. If you're in need of garage door service Ellicott City MD, look no further. Our experienced team offers comprehensive services, including repairs, maintenance, and new installations. We handle all types of garage doors and openers, ensuring smooth and reliable operation. Whether it's a broken spring, a malfunctioning opener, or routine maintenance, we provide prompt and professional service.

    We prioritize customer satisfaction, offering competitive pricing and 24/7 emergency assistance. Trust us to keep your garage door in top condition, enhancing the safety and convenience of your home. Contact us today for all your garage door needs.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The debate between Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens on religion was truly thought-provoking. It's fascinating to see such contrasting viewpoints dissected with such intellect and passion. On a different note, I recently learned about the importance of addressing Vitamin D deficiency Dubai, especially considering the lack of sunlight exposure for many residents. It's crucial to raise awareness and ensure proper medical guidance, perhaps someone like Dr. Karin Vela could shed more light on this topic with her diverse medical expertise.


    ReplyDelete