Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Mealy Mouthed Christians

Have you noticed a change in the arguments used by Christians when they want to impose their views on others?  Three generations ago the arguments were very clear, and explicitly religious. They went like this:
  • You must not drink alcohol because it is a sin and will lead you to hell.
  • You must not gamble because it is a blasphemy against God and he will damn you for all eternity.
  • You must not fornicate because the Bible tells us that fornication is a serious crime against God.
  •  You must not masturbate because it will cause all sorts of illness that reflect the mortal sin in your soul.
  • You must not allow abortions because they are prohibited in the Bible, and have been forbidden by the Church since biblical times.
  •  If you allow equality for women you will flout the Bible and Saint Paul, flying in the face of God, and doing Satan's work. The women will suffer from the vapours, hysteria, epilepsy and other serious medical consequences.
  • We must execute homosexuals because God considers homosexuality an “abomination”
  • We cannot allow suicide, euthanasia or heart transplants, because that would be “playing God” – usurping the divine monopoly and upsetting God’s plans for bodily resurrection on the Day of Judgement.

Since the Second World War Christian arguments have changed remarkably, at least  among the mainstream Churches. Now only fringe groups hold to the traditional line, citing the nastier parts of the Old Testament and threatening Satan's hell-fire to anyone who ignores them. Mainstream Churches have found new ways to try to impose their ideas on others. 

The first one is the "slippery slope" argument. Drinking alcohol is not so bad itself, but if you drink you might well become dependent on drink and then become an alcoholic and ruin your life. You should not gamble for the same reason. It will lead you into a life of misery and destroy your family. If you tolerate same sex marriage then soon people will be demanding the right to marry animals (I’m not making this up - this is a real argument). If you permit euthanasia even in the strictest conditions it will be the thin end of the wedge. In no time rapacious individuals will be encouraging their elderly relative to do away with themselves. Churches like this mode argument for perhaps three reasons. First it can be applied to almost anything they dislike. Second, it does not need any supporting evidence. Third it allows the Churches to portray themselves as loving and caring, with other people’s interests at heart.

The next mode of argument is a development of an old argument that they once used for masturbation and women's rights – imaginary medical consequences. If you use contraception you will spread various diseases (the opposite of the truth). If you have an abortion, you stand a high risk of dying or at the very least becoming infertile (untrue). If you use fetal stem cells, you might catch AIDS (untrue). A generation ago medical arguments were used liberally by Christians opposed to organ transplants, but those arguments have diminished now to almost nothing.

The interesting thing about both of these modes of argument is that there is no religious element to them at all. As the Churches know, religious arguments are toxic. They convince no one, and offend many. In most western countries we have not heard the mainstream Churches articulate a religious argument to justify their desire to prohibit people doing things for several years now. Religious groups peddling religious nonsense have been superseded by "faith groups" peddling irrational nonsense.

I suppose it’s a victory of sorts.


  1. Oh! This article has suggested to me many new ideas. I will embark on doing it. Hope you can continue to contribute your talents in this area. Thank you.

  2. Mom, too.TALK ISN CHEAPMarshawn Lynch is appealing his $100,000 fine, levied by the league after his latest dash to avoid the media.This time, it happened after the Seahawks loss last weekend.The NFL media policy stipulates players must be available at least once a week during practices and after every game.Some play a little fast and loose with the rule.Even when they talk, they say little.Last year, Lynch was fined $50,000 for violating the policy, but the league deferred the fine, as long as he co operated in the future.This time, when reporters got to the dressing room, Lynch was already headed for the team bus.When the agent suggested he go back, Lynch told him: can even move. My back is killing me. Let see, running into 300 pound walls disguised as defensive linemen, is tolerable but hanging around to talk into a tape recorder for five minutes hurts way too much.ALL LOVIE DOVEYFormer Bears coach Lovie Smith returns to Chicago on Sunday.And if his Bucs beat Marc Trestman Bears, sports talk shows will be infiltrated with folks reminiscing about Smith being the greatest thing to leave town since Barack Obama.. (tags: Coach Outlet Store Online , Michael Kors Bags Sale, Coach Outlet Store, MK Outlet)

    Guest coach Bob Moliter. Former players, coaches, faculty, friends and fans welcome. Free. Everybody saw in game six. I think that was kind of the tipping point of the whole thing. Forcing overtime, and ultimately beating the San Antonio Spurs in the sixth game of the NBA Finals, Bosh revealed that it was notably challenging to accurately recollect what exactly had transpired with their season hanging in the balance: (tags: Jordan Shoes For Sale Cheap, 2020 Jordan Release Dates, Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet).

  3. I was surfing net and fortunately came across this site and found very interesting stuff here. Its really fun to read. I enjoyed a lot. Thanks for sharing this wonderful information. porn recovery for those who follow the Christian Faith

  4. You completed a few fine points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will go along with with your blog. truth about recovery for lust addicts

  5. It has fully emerged to crown Singapore's southern shores and undoubtedly placed her on the global map of residential landmarks. I still scored the more points than I ever have in a season for GS. I think you would be hard pressed to find somebody with the same consistency I have had over the years so I am happy with that. 먹튀검증

  6. I like this post! Our assignment writing service is here to ease your academic burden by assisting you to ace all your papers with ease and convenience. Information about customers is confidential and never disclosed to third parties.

  7. It might be tempting to believe that betting on sports is just a game of luck, but experienced bettors will tell you otherwise. As with any hobby, there are thrill seekers and casual bettors - but you need to know the rules before you start placing bets. Access casino review and stay inside.

  8. Your blogs are really good and interesting. Three generations ago the arguments were very clear, and explicitly religious. They went like this: divorce law in virginia It is very great and informative. Keep sharing more useful blogs...

  9. Your article is unique and it's informative. Keep share more post. Abogado Defensa de Criminal Condado de Fairfax